All city: New York 1947.

1947 all New York City selections are in bold.  Lefty pitchers are in Italics.  Pyth is Pythagorean W-L (estimate of a team's winning percentage given their runs scored and runs allowed).  Comments below.  Click link to view data for years 1947-1957.  Seeing the players in a matrix may have some surprises.  Batting data below sorted by OPS+ per team.

	New York Giants	Brooklyn Dodgers	New York Yankees
C	Walker Cooper	Bruce Edwards	Aaron Robinson
1B	Johnny Mize	Jackie Robinson	George McQuinn
2B	Bill Rigney	Eddie Stanky	Snuffy Stirnweiss
SS	Buddy Kerr	Pee Wee Reese	Phil Rizzuto
3B	Jack Lohrke	Spider Jorgensen	Billy Johnson
LF	Sid Gordon	Dixie Walker	Johnny Lindell
CF	Bobby Thomson	Pete Reiser	Joe DiMaggio
RF	Willard Marshall	Carl Furillo	Tommy Henrich
P	Larry Jansen	Ralph Branca	Allie Reynolds
P	Dave Koslo	Joe Hatten	Spec Shea
P	Monty Kennedy	Vic Lombardi	Bill Bevens
P	Clint Hartung	Harry Taylor	Spud Chandler
Man.	Mel Ott	Burt Shotton	Bucky Harris
W-L	81-73	94-60	97-57
Pyth	83-71	92-62	100-54
Dif	-2	2	-3
Rank	4	1	1
			WS

WS		lost	won
Attend.	1,600,793	1,807,526	2,178,937
Att rank	2	1	1
1947	New York Giants	Brooklyn Dodgers	New York Yankees

Rk	Pos		Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+ ▾	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB
1	1B	Johnny Mize*	34	154	664	586	137	177	26	2	51	138	2		74	42	.302	.384	.614	.998	160	360	6	4	0
2	C	Walker Cooper	32	140	547	515	79	157	24	8	35	122	2		24	43	.305	.339	.586	.926	140	302	13	3	4
3	OF	Willard Marshall*	26	155	655	587	102	171	19	6	36	107	3		67	30	.291	.366	.528	.894	134	310	14	2	0
4	OF	Bobby Thomson	23	138	591	545	105	154	26	5	29	85	1		40	78	.283	.336	.508	.844	120	277	11	4	2
5	OF	Sid Gordon	29	130	491	437	57	119	19	8	13	57	2		50	21	.272	.347	.442	.789	107	193	11	0	3
6	2B	Bill Rigney	29	130	597	531	84	142	24	3	17	59	7		51	54	.267	.337	.420	.757	99	223	10	5	9
7	3B	Jack Lohrke	23	112	385	329	44	79	12	4	11	35	3		46	29	.240	.337	.401	.738	94	132	11	2	8
8	SS	Buddy Kerr	24	138	595	547	73	157	23	5	7	49	2		36	49	.287	.331	.386	.717	89	211	12	0	13

Rk	Pos		Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+ ▾	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB
1	SS	Pee Wee Reese	28	142	589	476	81	135	24	4	12	73	7		104	67	.284	.414	.426	.841	121	203	7	2	8
2	OF	Dixie Walker*	36	148	637	529	77	162	31	3	9	94	6		97	26	.306	.415	.427	.842	121	226	9	1	10
3	OF	Pete Reiser*	28	110	462	388	68	120	23	2	5	46	14		68	41	.309	.415	.418	.832	119	162	3	2	4
4	1B	Jackie Robinson	28	151	701	590	125	175	31	5	12	48	29		74	36	.297	.383	.427	.810	112	252	5	9	28
5	C	Bruce Edwards	23	130	528	471	53	139	15	8	9	80	2		49	55	.295	.364	.418	.782	105	197	10	2	6
6	OF	Carl Furillo	25	124	476	437	61	129	24	7	8	88	7		34	24	.295	.347	.437	.785	104	191	17	1	4
7	3B	Spider Jorgensen*	27	129	506	441	57	121	29	8	5	67	4		58	45	.274	.360	.410	.770	102	181	5	1	6
8	2B	Eddie Stanky	31	146	680	559	97	141	24	5	3	53	3		103	39	.252	.373	.329	.702	86	184	7	5	12

Rk	Pos		Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+ ▾	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB
1	OF	Joe DiMaggio	32	141	601	534	97	168	31	10	20	97	3	0	64	32	.315	.391	.522	.913	154	279	14	3	0
2	OF	Tommy Henrich*	34	142	629	550	109	158	35	13	16	98	3	2	71	54	.287	.372	.485	.857	138	267	9	3	5
3	1B	George McQuinn*	37	144	609	517	84	157	24	3	13	80	0	2	78	66	.304	.395	.437	.832	132	226	6	0	14
4	3B	Billy Johnson	28	132	545	494	67	141	19	8	10	95	1	2	44	43	.285	.351	.417	.768	114	206	21	6	3
5	OF	Johnny Lindell	30	127	513	476	66	131	18	7	11	67	1	2	32	70	.275	.322	.412	.734	104	196	15	1	4
6	SS	Phil Rizzuto	29	153	623	549	78	150	26	9	2	60	11	6	57	31	.273	.350	.364	.714	99	200	6	8	9
7	2B	Snuffy Stirnweiss	28	148	673	571	102	146	18	8	5	41	5	3	89	47	.256	.358	.342	.700	96	195	13	2	11

Joe DiMaggio 1951 Spring Training in Phoenix, AZ
by Warner Pathe News (Prelinger Archives)
via Wikimedia Commons

Joe DiMaggio was 1947 AL MVP.  Jackie Robinson was 1947 NL Rookie of the Year.  Yanks beat the Dodgers in a seven game World Series.  Giant home run hitters: Mize 51, Marshall 36, Cooper 35.  Pee Wee Reese beat Phil Rizzuto.

Easy: Cooper, Mize, Reese, DiMaggio, Marshall, Branca.

2B: who cares?

3B: Who?

Picking a manager was difficult, especially since the Yankees managed by Harris won the 1947 WS, but Shotton was all city.