All city: New York 1952.

1952 all New York City selections are in bold.  Lefty pitchers are in Italics.  Pyth is Pythagorean W-L (estimate of a team's winning percentage given their runs scored and runs allowed).  Comments below.  Click link to view data for years 1947-1957.  Seeing the players in a matrix may have some surprises.  Batting data below sorted by OPS+ per team.

1952	New York Giants	Brooklyn Dodgers	New York Yankees
C	Wes Westrum	Roy Campanella	Yogi Berra
1B	Whitey Lockman	Gil Hodges	Joe Collins
2B	Davey Williams	Jackie Robinson	Billy Martin
SS	Al Dark	Pee Wee Reese	Phil Rizzuto
3B	Bobby Thomson	Billy Cox	Gil McDougald
LF	Hank Thompson	Andy Pafko	Gene Woodling
CF	Bob Elliott	Duke Snider	Mickey Mantle
RF	Don Mueller	Carl Furillo	Hank Bauer
P	Sal Maglie	Carl Erskine	Allie Reynolds
P	Jim Hearn	Billy Loes	Eddie Lopat
P	Dave Koslo	Preacher Roe	Vic Raschi
P	Larry Jansen	Ben Wade	Tom Morgan
Man.	Leo Durocher	Chuck Dressen	Casey Stengel
W-L	92-62	96-57	95-59
Pyth	86-68	94-59	95-59
Dif	6	2
Rank	3	1	1
WS		lost	won
Attend.	984,940	1,088,704	1,629,665
Att rank	3	1	1
1952	New York Giants	Brooklyn Dodgers	New York Yankees

Rk	Pos		Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+ ▾	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB
1	3B	Bobby Thomson	28	153	666	608	89	164	29	14	24	108	5	2	52	74	.270	.331	.482	.813	122	293	16	4	2
2	OF	Hank Thompson*	26	128	486	423	67	110	13	9	17	67	4	4	50	38	.260	.344	.454	.798	119	192	7	4	7
3	SS	Al Dark	30	151	650	589	92	177	29	3	14	73	6	6	47	39	.301	.357	.431	.788	117	254	10	5	8
4	C	Wes Westrum	29	114	403	322	47	71	11	0	14	43	1	2	76	68	.220	.374	.385	.759	110	124	5	3	2
5	1B	Whitey Lockman*	25	154	687	606	99	176	17	4	13	58	2	4	67	52	.290	.363	.396	.759	109	240	8	2	11
6	OF	Don Mueller*	25	126	496	456	61	128	14	7	12	49	2	1	34	24	.281	.333	.421	.754	107	192	8	2	4
7	2B	Davey Williams	24	138	604	540	70	137	26	3	13	55	2	3	48	63	.254	.324	.385	.709	95	208	6	8	9
8	OF	Bob Elliott	35	98	313	272	33	62	6	2	10	35	1	0	36	20	.228	.323	.375	.698	92	102	7	2	3

Rk	Pos		Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+ ▾	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB
1	2B	Jackie Robinson	33	149	636	510	104	157	17	3	19	75	24	7	106	40	.308	.440	.465	.904	149	237	16	14	6
2	1B	Gil Hodges	28	153	619	508	87	129	27	1	32	102	2	4	107	90	.254	.386	.500	.886	142	254	9	2	2
3	OF	Duke Snider*	25	144	598	534	80	162	25	7	21	92	7	4	55	77	.303	.368	.494	.863	135	264	17	0	9
4	C	Roy Campanella	30	128	533	468	73	126	18	1	22	97	8	4	57	59	.269	.352	.453	.805	120	212	22	3	5
5	OF	Andy Pafko	31	150	624	551	76	158	17	5	19	85	4	3	64	48	.287	.366	.439	.805	120	242	14	5	4
6	SS	Pee Wee Reese	33	149	660	559	94	152	18	8	6	58	30	5	86	59	.272	.369	.365	.734	102	204	16	0	15
7	OF	Carl Furillo	30	134	462	425	52	105	18	1	8	59	1	4	31	33	.247	.304	.351	.655	80	149	16	4	2
8	3B	Billy Cox	32	116	490	455	56	118	12	3	6	34	10	12	25	32	.259	.301	.338	.639	75	154	13	2	8

Rk	Pos		Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+ ▾	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB
1	OF	Mickey Mantle#	20	142	626	549	94	171	37	7	23	87	4	1	75	111	.311	.394	.530	.924	162	291	5	0	2
2	OF	Gene Woodling*	29	122	471	408	58	126	19	6	12	63	1	4	59	31	.309	.397	.473	.870	148	193	5	1	3
3	1B	Joe Collins*	29	122	489	428	69	120	16	8	18	59	4	2	55	47	.280	.364	.481	.845	140	206	11	1	5
4	C	Yogi Berra*	27	142	603	534	97	146	17	1	30	98	2	3	66	24	.273	.358	.478	.835	137	255	8	4	1
5	OF	Hank Bauer	29	141	615	553	86	162	31	6	17	74	6	7	50	61	.293	.355	.463	.818	132	256	10	3	9
6	3B	Gil McDougald	24	152	633	555	65	146	16	5	11	78	6	5	57	73	.263	.336	.369	.705	101	205	14	4	16
7	SS	Phil Rizzuto	34	152	673	578	89	147	24	10	2	43	17	6	67	42	.254	.337	.341	.678	94	197	9	5	23
8	2B	Billy Martin	24	109	401	363	32	97	13	3	3	33	3	6	22	31	.267	.323	.344	.668	91	125	8	8	8

Yogi Berra Baseball Digest, front cover
September 1956 via Wikimedia Commons

20 year old Mickey Mantle emerged as a star with a whopping OPS+ 162 and displaced 25 year old Duke Snider after Snider made all city for the first time in 1951.  Willie Mays played 34 games, then left for the U.S. Army.  Mays returned in 1954 with spectacular results.  Don Newcombe, best Dodger starting pitcher, was also off to the Army.  Berra replaced Campanella as all city catcher.  Dark again beat Rizzuto and Reese.  The Yankees had new starting infielders: Billy Martin 2B, Gil McDougald 3B.

Leo Durocher again substantially exceeded his Pyth, this time by 6 games.  In 1951 it was 5 but that was with sign stealing, which supposedly had stopped.  Chuck Dressen overcame the 1951 collapse and won the pennant but Casey Stengel led the Yankees to their fourth consecutive World Series championship.  The Yanks won games 6 and 7 in Ebbets Field led my Mantle.

Only 30,037 fans showed up to see the Dodgers try to close out the WS in game 6.  Note the attendance for all the games.  Fewer fans at games 6 and 7 than at games 1 and 2.  All were weekdays.

1 - 34,861 Wednesday, October 1, 1952 Ebbets Field
2 - 33,792 Thursday, October 2, 1952 Ebbets Field
3 - 66,698 Friday, October 3, 1952 Yankee Stadium
4 - 71,787 Saturday, October 4, 1952 Yankee Stadium
5 - 70,536 Sunday, October 5, 1952 Yankee Stadium
6 - 30,037 Monday, October 6, 1952 Ebbets Field
7 - 33,195 Tuesday, October 7, 1952 Ebbets Field

The Yankees continued to dominate regular season attendance, although the Dodgers and Giants finished first and second in NL attendance.

Hoyt Wilhelm pitched 159 innings for the Giants with no starts: 15-3; Sal Maglie: 18-8.  Carl Erskine, Billy Loes and Preacher Roe led the Dodger starters.  For the Yankees Allie Reynolds had his career year (20-8, ERA+ 161) followed by Eddie Lopat, Vic Raschi and Tom Morgan.