Aaron Judge has only 4,561 career PA through June 19, 2025 (age 33 season).

Aaron Judge

Position: Rightfielder

Bats: Right  •  Throws: Right

6-7, 282lb (201cm, 127kg)

Team: New York Yankees (majors)

Born: April 26, 1992 (Age: 33-055d) in Linden, CA

Age of Aaron Judge: 33 years, 55 days.

The point here is that Aaron Judge, as great as he is, has had a short career, only 4,561 Plate Appearances (PA), that is unlikely to become a long career because he is already 33.

Maybe Judge will be productive to age 40.  But two of the players on the Yankees Mt. Rushmore were finished at 36:

Joe DiMaggio: cumulative PA through age 33 season: 6,255

Mickey Mantle: cumulative PA through age 33 season: 8,417

Mt. Rushmore: Ruth, Gehrig, DiMaggio, Mantle. Giants come close.  Tuesday, June 25, 2024

 
Baseball players only, no pitchers.

__________________________

164 batters meet this criteria:

https://stathead.com/tiny/fFkbm

For combined seasons, since 1903, age 33 or younger, Playing in the AL or NL, in the regular season, requiring Wins Above Replacement (WAR) >= 20 and Plate Appearances <= 4651, sorted by descending Plate Appearances.

Top 20 in PA:

Rk	Player	PA	WAR	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	oWAR	dWAR
1	Aaron Judge	4651	57.8	2016	2025	24-33	1067	3840	802	1127	341	776	59	19	741	1293	.293	.410	.613	1.023	177	2355	52.2	2.3
2	Larry Hisle	4647	24.7	1968	1980	21-33	1161	4087	634	1122	160	658	128	61	451	911	.275	.349	.454	.803	124	1855	26.9	-5.5
3	Phil Garner	4646	22.3	1973	1982	24-33	1208	4168	507	1097	71	498	182	79	365	531	.263	.323	.394	.718	100	1644	19.8	6.6
4	Johnny Mize	4634	50.5	1936	1946	23-33	1097	4039	713	1340	206	833	20	8	546	344	.332	.415	.587	1.002	171	2371	50.0	-4.8
5	Corey Seager	4628	38.2	2015	2025	21-31	1073	4127	660	1190	206	631	18	8	436	826	.288	.359	.507	.866	135	2091	38.1	5.7
6	Bill North	4621	26.8	1971	1981	23-33	1169	3900	640	1016	20	230	395	162	627	665	.261	.365	.323	.688	100	1258	22.9	3.8
7	Muddy Ruel	4612	20.6	1915	1929	19-33	1246	3927	442	1105	4	467	59	65	519	203	.281	.369	.339	.708	87	1332	17.0	7.8
8	Ray Chapman	4608	29.3	1912	1920	21-29	1051	3785	671	1053	17	364	238	52	452	427	.278	.358	.377	.735	111	1428	32.8	4.4
9	Minnie Miñoso	4601	36.9	1949	1957	25-33	1049	3869	714	1189	101	619	145	83	537	316	.307	.405	.475	.880	137	1838	32.8	-0.4
10	Bobby Ávila	4593	27.5	1949	1957	25-33	1094	3981	634	1141	69	412	70	45	472	307	.287	.363	.394	.757	106	1569	26.4	5.3
11	Ray Boone	4580	24.7	1948	1957	24-33	1133	3971	569	1110	133	642	18	16	522	377	.280	.365	.437	.802	117	1735	26.5	0.6
12	Rafael Devers	4562	25.0	2017	2025	20-28	1056	4085	663	1139	215	697	33	19	416	974	.279	.349	.510	.859	129	2082	31.0	-4.3
13	Danny Murphy	4561	29.2	1903	1910	26-33	1119	4150	496	1170	31	524	143		226	242	.282	.324	.398	.722	124	1653	27.7	-1.0
14	Frank McCormick	4558	26.5	1934	1944	23-33	1076	4207	563	1279	100	722	17	13	283	127	.304	.351	.445	.796	122	1871	21.3	-0.1
15	Mookie Wilson	4555	20.9	1980	1989	24-33	1170	4265	624	1183	62	359	293	91	243	729	.277	.318	.392	.711	100	1674	20.2	-0.1
16	Billy Southworth	4552	21.3	1913	1926	20-33	1081	4021	608	1198	50	519	128	92	377	137	.298	.360	.417	.777	113	1676	17.9	-1.4
17	Mickey Tettleton	4551	26.3	1984	1994	23-33	1191	3734	552	905	186	567	21	28	744	1048	.242	.368	.443	.811	124	1655	30.9	-0.9
18	Kris Bryant	4550	27.4	2015	2025	23-33	1054	3919	667	1068	184	548	44	20	504	1064	.273	.368	.483	.851	125	1891	29.4	-2.7
19	Ferris Fain	4547	25.7	1947	1954	26-33	1037	3672	563	1072	46	539	41	27	810	236	.292	.422	.401	.822	121	1472	24.0	-3.4
20	Charlie Keller	4529	43.2	1939	1950	22-33	1114	3727	719	1069	186	739	45	23	773	486	.287	.411	.519	.930	153	1935	39.3	-0.9
Rk	Player	PA	WAR	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	oWAR	dWAR

Like Judge, these are still active: Seager, Devers, Bryant. Of those 3, only Bryant is 33.

Let's look at all 164 batters and sort on some fields.

Sorted on WAR (Note 7 Hall Of Famers in BOLD; 3 show only part of their careers from 1903 on):

Rk	Player	PA	WAR ▼	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	oWAR	dWAR
1	Aaron Judge	4651	57.8	2016	2025	24-33	1067	3840	802	1127	341	776	59	19	741	1293	.293	.410	.613	1.023	177	2355	52.2	2.3
2	Johnny Mize	4634	50.5	1936	1946	23-33	1097	4039	713	1340	206	833	20	8	546	344	.332	.415	.587	1.002	171	2371	50.0	-4.8
3	Nap Lajoie	3275	45.0	1903	1908	28-33	776	2979	429	992	18	464	120		175	120	.333	.377	.455	.832	161	1356	35.3	10.1
4	Honus Wagner	2928	44.4	1903	1907	29-33	692	2581	509	907	23	430	270		261	185	.351	.418	.503	.921	176	1298	41.9	7.8
5	Jackie Robinson	3944	44.1	1947	1952	28-33	900	3333	664	1060	92	501	149	61	482	191	.318	.412	.483	.895	137	1610	39.9	7.2
6	Charlie Keller	4529	43.2	1939	1950	22-33	1114	3727	719	1069	186	739	45	23	773	486	.287	.411	.519	.930	153	1935	39.3	-0.9
7	Josh Donaldson	4476	40.9	2010	2019	24-33	1038	3841	652	1048	219	645	38	8	557	885	.273	.369	.509	.878	136	1955	37.6	5.5
8	Matt Chapman	4507	40.6	2017	2025	24-32	1087	3943	620	952	194	534	33	16	485	1199	.241	.331	.461	.792	119	1818	29.3	14.2
9	Juan Soto	4420	39.3	2018	2025	19-26	1010	3546	707	1000	215	629	65	24	830	748	.282	.418	.527	.945	159	1868	40.8	-5.0
10	Corey Seager	4628	38.2	2015	2025	21-31	1073	4127	660	1190	206	631	18	8	436	826	.288	.359	.507	.866	135	2091	38.1	5.7
11	Frank Chance	3836	37.6	1903	1910	26-33	924	3211	597	970	16	457	311		417	224	.302	.397	.402	.800	141	1292	31.4	3.2
12	Roger Bresnahan	3825	37.0	1903	1912	24-33	989	3124	514	901	18	375	144		554	272	.288	.405	.389	.794	138	1216	34.6	7.1
13	Minnie Miñoso	4601	36.9	1949	1957	25-33	1049	3869	714	1189	101	619	145	83	537	316	.307	.405	.475	.880	137	1838	32.8	-0.4
14	Art Fletcher	4504	36.1	1909	1918	24-33	1153	4107	527	1132	18	507	144	36	157	270	.276	.321	.357	.679	102	1468	23.7	21.1
15	Lorenzo Cain	4295	36.0	2010	2019	24-33	1045	3894	565	1122	78	407	175	40	325	768	.288	.347	.413	.761	104	1610	22.7	15.3
16	Edgar Martínez	3911	35.7	1987	1996	24-33	936	3276	604	1031	117	484	30	20	555	465	.315	.417	.507	.924	147	1660	34.2	-0.3
17	Ben Zobrist	4478	35.3	2006	2014	25-33	1064	3850	565	1016	114	511	102	35	542	701	.264	.354	.429	.783	117	1651	29.0	7.8
18	Kevin Kiermaier	3759	35.3	2013	2023	23-33	1043	3423	468	854	90	352	126	37	265	822	.249	.309	.409	.718	98	1399	17.8	19.7
19	Wally Schang	4318	35.2	1913	1923	23-33	1195	3573	521	1025	30	450	99	29	538	394	.287	.393	.397	.790	124	1420	35.6	4.0
20	Roy Campanella	3975	34.4	1948	1955	26-33	988	3487	557	996	209	721	23	20	433	390	.286	.368	.522	.890	131	1820	30.8	7.7

Sort on OPS+:

Rk	Player	OPS+	PA	WAR	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB	WAR	WAA	oWAR	dWAR
1	Aaron Judge	177	4651	57.8	2016	2025	24-33	1067	3840	802	1127	341	776	59	19	741	1293	.293	.410	.613	1.023	2355	57.8	42.8	52.2	2.3
2	Honus Wagner	176	2928	44.4	1903	1907	29-33	692	2581	509	907	23	430	270		261	185	.351	.418	.503	.921	1298	44.4	34.7	41.9	7.8
3	Johnny Mize	171	4634	50.5	1936	1946	23-33	1097	4039	713	1340	206	833	20	8	546	344	.332	.415	.587	1.002	2371	50.5	34.0	50.0	-4.8
4	Yordan Alvarez	162	2789	23.1	2019	2025	22-28	658	2390	419	704	167	484	9	1	334	554	.295	.387	.573	.959	1369	23.1	13.9	23.5	-5.0
5	Nap Lajoie	161	3275	45.0	1903	1908	28-33	776	2979	429	992	18	464	120		175	120	.333	.377	.455	.832	1356	45.0	32.4	35.3	10.1
6	Juan Soto	159	4420	39.3	2018	2025	19-26	1010	3546	707	1000	215	629	65	24	830	748	.282	.418	.527	.945	1868	39.3	25.5	40.8	-5.0
7	Shohei Ohtani	159	3947	32.3	2018	2025	23-30	934	3414	635	964	250	610	156	41	477	1004	.282	.372	.579	.951	1975	32.3	20.9	32.1	-8.0
8	Charlie Keller	153	4529	43.2	1939	1950	22-33	1114	3727	719	1069	186	739	45	23	773	486	.287	.411	.519	.930	1935	43.2	29.2	39.3	-0.9
9	Mike Donlin	152	2708	20.7	1903	1911	25-33	638	2418	415	821	27	354	129		196	178	.340	.392	.472	.864	1141	20.7	12.1	21.8	-3.8
10	Elmer Flick	148	3475	28.4	1903	1909	27-33	801	3045	460	914	16	308	186		298	371	.300	.371	.425	.795	1293	28.4	15.4	27.4	-3.5
11	Edgar Martínez	147	3911	35.7	1987	1996	24-33	936	3276	604	1031	117	484	30	20	555	465	.315	.417	.507	.924	1660	35.7	22.4	34.2	-0.3
12	Kevin Mitchell	146	4246	29.1	1984	1994	22-32	1088	3742	582	1070	220	689	29	31	436	652	.286	.361	.529	.890	1979	29.1	15.1	32.5	-6.5
13	George Stone	144	3677	26.2	1903	1910	26-33	848	3271	426	984	23	268	132		282	425	.301	.360	.396	.756	1295	26.2	12.4	25.1	-4.4
14	Ken Williams	143	3107	26.2	1915	1923	25-33	735	2682	494	866	108	488	105	65	312	181	.323	.398	.541	.938	1450	26.2	14.5	24.6	-1.4
15	Cy Seymour	143	2467	20.2	1903	1906	30-33	566	2246	321	741	28	331	86		155	126	.330	.376	.464	.841	1043	20.2	12.3	18.1	0.7
16	Ronald Acuña Jr.	141	3358	27.4	2018	2025	20-27	746	2903	604	847	173	431	197	49	387	742	.292	.383	.530	.913	1538	27.4	17.3	27.4	-1.9
17	Frank Chance	141	3836	37.6	1903	1910	26-33	924	3211	597	970	16	457	311		417	224	.302	.397	.402	.800	1292	37.6	24.8	31.4	3.2
18	Kyle Tucker	141	2886	25.8	2018	2025	21-28	706	2513	416	691	138	460	112	14	325	457	.275	.358	.515	.873	1295	25.8	16.4	22.0	1.2
19	Bob Johnson	140	4440	32.3	1933	1939	27-33	1023	3814	728	1168	186	750	61	41	593	478	.306	.401	.537	.938	2049	32.3	16.7	31.5	-2.6
20	Travis Hafner	139	3852	22.5	2002	2010	25-33	941	3252	524	913	176	603	9	7	498	772	.281	.385	.517	.902	1681	22.5	8.8	22.8	-7.8
Rk	Player	OPS+	PA	WAR	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB	WAR	WAA	oWAR	dWAR

In addition to Judge, active batters: Alvarez, Soto, Ohtani, Acuni, Tucker.

Finally, sorted on Home Runs:

Rk	Player	OPS+	PA	WAR	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H ▼	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB	WAR	WAA	oWAR	dWAR
1	Aaron Judge	177	4651	57.8	2016	2025	24-33	1067	3840	802	1127	341	776	59	19	741	1293	.293	.410	.613	1.023	2355	57.8	42.8	52.2	2.3
2	Shohei Ohtani	159	3947	32.3	2018	2025	23-30	934	3414	635	964	250	610	156	41	477	1004	.282	.372	.579	.951	1975	32.3	20.9	32.1	-8.0
3	Pete Alonso	137	3937	22.6	2019	2025	24-30	921	3421	535	863	243	649	17	4	393	894	.252	.343	.518	.861	1772	22.6	10.1	23.0	-5.2
4	Kevin Mitchell	146	4246	29.1	1984	1994	22-32	1088	3742	582	1070	220	689	29	31	436	652	.286	.361	.529	.890	1979	29.1	15.1	32.5	-6.5
5	Josh Donaldson	136	4476	40.9	2010	2019	24-33	1038	3841	652	1048	219	645	38	8	557	885	.273	.369	.509	.878	1955	40.9	26.0	37.6	5.5
6	Bob Horner	127	4213	21.9	1978	1988	20-30	1020	3777	560	1047	218	685	14	18	369	512	.277	.340	.499	.839	1886	21.9	7.4	28.2	-7.4
7	Rafael Devers	129	4562	25.0	2017	2025	20-28	1056	4085	663	1139	215	697	33	19	416	974	.279	.349	.510	.859	2082	25.0	10.1	31.0	-4.3
8	Juan Soto	159	4420	39.3	2018	2025	19-26	1010	3546	707	1000	215	629	65	24	830	748	.282	.418	.527	.945	1868	39.3	25.5	40.8	-5.0
9	Roy Campanella	131	3975	34.4	1948	1955	26-33	988	3487	557	996	209	721	23	20	433	390	.286	.368	.522	.890	1820	34.4	19.1	30.8	7.7
10	Corey Seager	135	4628	38.2	2015	2025	21-31	1073	4127	660	1190	206	631	18	8	436	826	.288	.359	.507	.866	2091	38.2	23.6	38.1	5.7
11	Cody Bellinger	120	4397	26.9	2017	2025	21-29	1073	3897	638	1008	206	635	98	24	439	911	.259	.333	.481	.815	1876	26.9	12.8	22.8	2.4
12	Johnny Mize	171	4634	50.5	1936	1946	23-33	1097	4039	713	1340	206	833	20	8	546	344	.332	.415	.587	1.002	2371	50.5	34.0	50.0	-4.8
13	Eric Davis	125	4280	27.6	1984	1994	22-32	1100	3695	665	957	205	645	306	45	533	975	.259	.353	.477	.829	1761	27.6	13.5	32.3	-5.8
14	Mike Napoli	123	4200	25.7	2006	2015	24-33	1118	3590	545	910	204	577	33	21	523	1111	.253	.355	.482	.837	1731	25.7	10.7	26.8	-0.7
15	José Abreu	136	4168	24.0	2014	2020	27-33	961	3787	526	1114	198	671	10	5	263	835	.294	.350	.520	.870	1969	24.0	9.9	25.7	-7.2
16	Max Muncy	123	3592	23.3	2015	2024	24-33	920	2980	545	679	195	537	14	4	540	886	.228	.352	.475	.826	1415	23.3	11.6	21.3	1.2
17	Matt Chapman	119	4507	40.6	2017	2025	24-32	1087	3943	620	952	194	534	33	16	485	1199	.241	.331	.461	.792	1818	40.6	25.6	29.3	14.2
18	Don Mincher	128	4419	21.3	1960	1971	22-33	1292	3781	505	950	194	599	22	29	550	629	.251	.347	.457	.805	1729	21.3	6.5	20.0	-5.0
19	Josh Hamilton	130	4168	27.7	2007	2014	26-33	977	3739	587	1091	192	676	50	16	342	886	.292	.352	.519	.871	1941	27.7	13.4	28.7	-2.6
20	Al Rosen	137	4374	32.3	1947	1956	23-32	1044	3725	603	1063	192	717	39	33	587	385	.285	.384	.495	.879	1844	32.3	18.9	31.5	0.4

Judge is way ahead. Final HR totals for:

Mize 359
Donaldson 279