wRC+ v. OPS+: top 25 in 2013

wRC+ is the new rage and supposedly more accurate.  OPS+ is easier to find and easier to understand.

Top 25 for each in 2013:

wRC+

fangraphs.com:

140 items in 5 pages
1	Miguel Cabrera	Tigers	148	652	44	103	137	3	13.8 %	14.4 %	.288	.356	.348	.442	.636	.455	192	-4.4	63.5	-14.8	7.6
2	Mike Trout	Angels	157	716	27	109	97	33	15.4 %	19.0 %	.234	.376	.323	.432	.557	.423	176	8.1	69.6	3.3	10.4
3	Chris Davis	Orioles	160	673	53	103	138	4	10.7 %	29.6 %	.348	.336	.286	.370	.634	.421	167	2.6	54.0	-13.5	6.8
4	Jayson Werth	Nationals	129	532	25	84	82	10	11.3 %	19.0 %	.214	.358	.318	.398	.532	.403	160	0.3	36.0	-9.0	4.6
5	Joey Votto	Reds	162	726	24	101	73	6	18.6 %	19.0 %	.186	.360	.305	.435	.491	.400	156	-0.6	45.4	-10.1	6.2
6	Paul Goldschmidt	Diamondbacks	160	710	36	103	125	15	13.9 %	20.4 %	.249	.343	.302	.401	.551	.404	156	0.4	45.0	-7.0	6.4
7	Andrew McCutchen	Pirates	157	674	21	97	84	27	11.6 %	15.0 %	.190	.353	.317	.404	.508	.393	155	5.1	46.9	9.3	8.2
8	David Ortiz	Red Sox	137	600	30	84	103	4	12.7 %	14.7 %	.255	.321	.309	.395	.564	.400	152	-4.4	30.9	-15.5	3.8
9	Shin-Soo Choo	Reds	154	712	21	107	54	20	15.7 %	18.7 %	.178	.338	.285	.423	.462	.393	151	-0.6	40.3	-13.3	5.2
10	Freddie Freeman	Braves	147	629	23	89	109	1	10.5 %	19.2 %	.181	.371	.319	.396	.501	.387	150	-1.2	34.0	-8.7	4.8
11	Matt Holliday	Cardinals	141	602	22	103	94	6	11.5 %	14.3 %	.190	.322	.300	.389	.490	.383	148	2.2	35.1	-11.4	4.5
12	Josh Donaldson	Athletics	158	668	24	89	93	5	11.4 %	16.5 %	.199	.333	.301	.384	.499	.384	148	1.1	37.3	12.1	7.7
13	Matt Carpenter	Cardinals	157	717	11	126	78	3	10.0 %	13.7 %	.163	.359	.318	.392	.481	.381	147	4.1	42.3	1.3	7.0
14	Edwin Encarnacion	Blue Jays	142	621	36	90	104	7	13.2 %	10.0 %	.262	.247	.272	.370	.534	.388	145	1.7	33.7	-15.9	4.1
15	Joe Mauer	Twins	113	508	11	62	47	0	12.0 %	17.5 %	.153	.383	.324	.404	.476	.383	144	-0.5	25.1	6.2	5.2
16	Troy Tulowitzki	Rockies	126	512	25	72	82	1	11.1 %	16.6 %	.229	.334	.312	.391	.540	.400	143	-0.6	24.3	11.9	5.6
17	Robinson Cano	Yankees	160	681	27	81	107	7	9.5 %	12.5 %	.202	.327	.314	.383	.516	.384	142	-2.0	30.6	2.5	6.0
18	Michael Cuddyer	Rockies	130	540	20	74	84	10	8.5 %	18.5 %	.198	.382	.331	.389	.530	.396	140	1.1	25.6	-18.5	2.5
19	Brandon Belt	Giants	150	571	17	76	67	5	9.1 %	21.9 %	.193	.351	.289	.360	.481	.365	139	0.0	24.8	-5.0	4.0
20	Brandon Moss	Athletics	145	505	30	73	87	4	9.9 %	27.7 %	.267	.301	.256	.337	.522	.369	137	-2.7	18.9	-18.0	1.9
21	Marlon Byrd	- - -	147	579	24	75	88	2	5.4 %	24.9 %	.220	.353	.291	.336	.511	.364	136	0.5	24.0	-3.7	4.1
22	Adrian Beltre	Rangers	161	690	30	88	92	1	7.2 %	11.3 %	.193	.322	.315	.371	.509	.379	135	-1.8	25.9	-0.7	5.2
23	Allen Craig	Cardinals	134	563	13	71	97	2	7.1 %	17.8 %	.142	.368	.315	.373	.457	.363	135	-5.9	16.2	-9.1	2.6
24	Giancarlo Stanton	Marlins	116	504	24	62	62	1	14.7 %	27.8 %	.231	.313	.249	.365	.480	.368	135	-0.3	19.4	-13.1	2.3
25	Carlos Santana	Indians	154	642	20	75	74	3	14.5 %	17.1 %	.187	.301	.268	.377	.455	.364	135	-4.3	21.0	-9.2	3.6

OPS+

Rk	Player	OPS+	PA	Year	Age	Tm	Lg	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	IBB	SO	HBP	SH	SF	GDP	SB	CS	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	Pos
1	Miguel Cabrera	187	652	2013	30	DET	AL	148	555	103	193	26	1	44	137	90	19	94	5	0	2	19	3	0	.348	.442	.636	1.078	*5/HD
2	Mike Trout	179	716	2013	21	LAA	AL	157	589	109	190	39	9	27	97	110	10	136	9	0	8	8	33	7	.323	.432	.557	.988	*87/D
3	Chris Davis	165	673	2013	27	BAL	AL	160	584	103	167	42	1	53	138	72	12	199	10	0	7	4	4	1	.286	.370	.634	1.004	*3/D
4	Paul Goldschmidt	160	710	2013	25	ARI	NL	160	602	103	182	36	3	36	125	99	19	145	3	0	5	25	15	7	.302	.401	.551	.952	*3/H
5	David Ortiz	160	600	2013	37	BOS	AL	137	518	84	160	38	2	30	103	76	27	88	1	0	5	21	4	0	.309	.395	.564	.959	*D/3H
6	Andrew McCutchen	158	674	2013	26	PIT	NL	157	583	97	185	38	5	21	84	78	12	101	9	0	4	13	27	10	.317	.404	.508	.911	*8/HD
7	Joey Votto	154	726	2013	29	CIN	NL	162	581	101	177	30	3	24	73	135	19	138	4	0	6	15	6	3	.305	.435	.491	.926	*3/H
8	Jayson Werth	154	532	2013	34	WSN	NL	129	462	84	147	24	0	25	82	60	3	101	5	0	5	9	10	1	.318	.398	.532	.931	*9/DH
9	Josh Donaldson	148	668	2013	27	OAK	AL	158	579	89	174	37	3	24	93	76	2	110	6	1	6	15	5	2	.301	.384	.499	.883	*5/D63
10	Robinson Cano	145	681	2013	30	NYY	AL	160	605	81	190	41	0	27	107	65	16	85	6	0	5	18	7	1	.314	.383	.516	.899	*4/D6
11	Edwin Encarnacion	145	621	2013	30	TOR	AL	142	530	90	144	29	1	36	104	82	7	62	4	0	5	20	7	1	.272	.370	.534	.904	*3D5
12	Joe Mauer	144	508	2013	30	MIN	AL	113	445	62	144	35	0	11	47	61	7	89	0	0	2	7	0	1	.324	.404	.476	.880	*2D/3H
13	Matt Holliday	144	602	2013	33	STL	NL	141	520	103	156	31	1	22	94	69	5	86	9	0	4	31	6	1	.300	.389	.490	.879	*7/DH
14	Freddie Freeman	144	629	2013	23	ATL	NL	147	551	89	176	27	2	23	109	66	10	121	7	0	5	10	1	0	.319	.396	.501	.897	*3/H
15	Shin-Soo Choo	143	712	2013	30	CIN	NL	154	569	107	162	34	2	21	54	112	5	133	26	3	2	3	20	11	.285	.423	.462	.885	*8/7H
16	Matt Carpenter	143	717	2013	27	STL	NL	157	626	126	199	55	7	11	78	72	1	98	9	3	7	4	3	3	.318	.392	.481	.873	*45/H39
17	Brandon Belt	142	571	2013	25	SFG	NL	150	509	76	147	39	4	17	67	52	4	125	6	1	3	4	5	2	.289	.360	.481	.841	*3H
18	Troy Tulowitzki	140	512	2013	28	COL	NL	126	446	72	139	27	0	25	82	57	5	85	4	0	5	9	1	0	.312	.391	.540	.931	*6/H
19	Brandon Moss	139	505	2013	29	OAK	AL	145	446	73	114	23	3	30	87	50	3	140	6	0	3	4	4	2	.256	.337	.522	.859	*39H/7D85
20	Buster Posey	138	595	2013	26	SFG	NL	148	520	61	153	34	1	15	72	60	8	70	8	0	7	15	2	1	.294	.371	.450	.821	*23/DH
21	Marlon Byrd	138	579	2013	35	TOT	NL	147	532	75	155	35	5	24	88	31	2	144	8	1	7	11	2	4	.291	.336	.511	.847	*9H/87
22	Carlos Santana	137	642	2013	27	CLE	AL	154	541	75	145	39	1	20	74	93	6	110	4	0	4	7	3	1	.268	.377	.455	.832	*2D3/H
23	Adrian Beltre	137	690	2013	34	TEX	AL	161	631	88	199	32	0	30	92	50	12	78	7	0	2	17	1	0	.315	.371	.509	.880	*5D
24	Michael Cuddyer	137	540	2013	34	COL	NL	130	489	74	162	31	3	20	84	46	5	100	2	0	3	13	10	3	.331	.389	.530	.919	*93/HD
25	Hunter Pence	136	687	2013	30	SFG	NL	162	629	91	178	35	5	27	99	52	3	115	3	0	3	17	22	3	.283	.339	.483	.822	*9
Rk	Player	OPS+	PA	Year	Age	Tm	Lg	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	IBB	SO	HBP	SH	SF	GDP	SB	CS	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	Pos

Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 12/3/2013.

Top three are the same guys.  Here they are in rank order with their OPS+ difference.  Positive means ranked higher in OPS+.  Negative means ranked lower in OPS+.

Rank	wRC+	OPS+	Rank Dif
1	Cabrera	Cabrera	0
2	Trout	Trout	0
3	Davis	Davis	0
4	Werth	Goldschmidt	2
5	Votto	Ortiz	3
6	Goldschmidt	McCutchen	1
7	McCutchen	Votto	-3
8	Ortiz	Werth	-4
9	Choo	Donaldson	3
10	Freeman	Cano	7
11	Holliday	Encarnacion	3
12	Donaldson	Mauer	3
13	Carpenter	Holliday	-2
14	Encarnacion	Freeman	-4
15	Mauer	Choo	-6
16	Tulowitzki	Carpenter	-3
17	Cano	Belt	2
18	Cuddyer	Tulowitzki	-2
19	Belt	Moss	1
20	Moss	Posey	9
21	Byrd	Byrd	0
22	Beltre	Santana	3
23	Craig	Beltre	-1
24	Stanton	Cuddyer	-6
25	Santana	Pence	5

Posey gets the biggest boost from OPS+ with Cano a close second.  Choo and Cuddyer get the biggest penalty from OPS+ for those in both lists.  In addition to the top three, Byrd is ranked 21 in both.  Neither Craig (23) nor Stanton (24) are in the top 25 for OPS+: Craig (30), Stanton (32).

in OPS+:

+1:
McCutchen
Moss

-1:
Beltre

+2:
Goldschmidt
Belt

-2:
Holliday
Tulowitzki

+3:
Ortiz
Donaldson
Encarnacion
Mauer
Santana

-3:
Votto
Carpenter

-4:
Werth
Freeman

+5:
Pence

-6:
Choo
Cuddyer

+7:
Cano

-7:
Craig

-8:
Stanton

+9:
Posey