Best hitting Yankee catchers of all time.

MVP:

Berra: 1951, 1954, 1955

Howard: 1963

Munson: 1976

HoF: Dickey, Berra

https://www.sports-reference.com/stathead/tiny/Ha8GW

For single seasons, At least 500 Plate Appearances, Played at least 75% of games at C, Playing for NYY, in the regular season, requiring Adjusted OPS+ >= 125 and Home Runs >= 0, sorted by descending Adjusted OPS+.

Rk	Player	OPS+	PA	HR	Season	Age	G	AB	R	H	1B	2B	3B	RBI	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB	Pos
1	Jorge Posada	153	589	20	2007	36	144	506	91	171	108	42	1	90	74	98	.338	.426	.543	.970	275	*2H/D3
2	Bill Dickey	144	609	29	1937	30	140	530	87	176	110	35	2	133	73	22	.332	.417	.570	.987	302	*2/H
3	Jorge Posada	144	588	30	2003	32	142	481	83	135	81	24	0	101	93	110	.281	.405	.518	.922	249	*2/HD
4	Bill Dickey	143	533	27	1938	31	132	454	84	142	84	27	4	115	75	22	.313	.412	.568	.981	258	*2/H
5	Thurman Munson	142	576	20	1973	26	147	519	80	156	103	29	4	74	48	64	.301	.362	.487	.849	253	*2/HD
6	Yogi Berra	142	597	30	1956	31	140	521	93	155	94	29	2	105	65	29	.298	.378	.534	.911	278	*2/H7
7	Elston Howard	141	531	28	1963	34	135	487	75	140	85	21	6	85	35	68	.287	.342	.528	.869	257	*2/H
8	Yogi Berra	141	557	27	1953	28	137	503	80	149	94	23	5	108	50	32	.296	.363	.523	.886	263	*2H
9	Jorge Posada	139	624	28	2000	29	151	505	92	145	81	35	1	86	107	151	.287	.417	.527	.943	266	*23/DH
10	Yogi Berra	137	605	30	1952	27	142	534	97	146	98	17	1	98	66	24	.273	.358	.478	.835	255	*2/H
11	Yogi Berra	137	652	22	1954	29	151	584	88	179	123	28	6	125	56	29	.307	.367	.488	.855	285	*2/H5
12	Bill Dickey	135	532	14	1933	26	130	478	58	152	106	24	8	97	47	14	.318	.381	.490	.871	234	*2/H
13	Yogi Berra	135	656	28	1950	25	151	597	116	192	128	30	6	124	55	12	.322	.383	.533	.915	318	*2/H
14	Bill Dickey	133	565	24	1939	32	128	480	98	145	95	23	3	105	77	37	.302	.403	.513	.915	246	*2/H
15	Jorge Posada	131	547	21	2004	33	137	449	72	122	70	31	0	81	88	92	.272	.400	.481	.881	216	*2H
16	Yogi Berra	130	594	27	1951	26	141	547	92	161	111	19	4	88	44	20	.294	.350	.492	.842	269	*2/H
17	Elston Howard	127	607	15	1964	35	150	550	63	172	127	27	3	84	48	73	.313	.371	.455	.825	250	*2/H
18	Thurman Munson	126	526	6	1970	23	132	453	59	137	102	25	4	53	57	56	.302	.386	.415	.801	188	*2H
19	Gary Sánchez	126	525	33	2017	24	122	471	79	131	78	20	0	90	40	120	.278	.345	.531	.876	250	2D/H3
20	Thurman Munson	126	665	17	1976	29	152	616	79	186	141	27	1	105	29	38	.302	.337	.432	.769	266	*2D/9H7
21	Thurman Munson	126	661	12	1975	28	157	597	83	190	151	24	3	102	45	52	.318	.366	.429	.795	256	*2D/3H579
22	Yogi Berra	125	521	19	1959	34	131	472	64	134	89	25	1	69	43	38	.284	.347	.462	.809	218	*2H/9

Provided by Stathead: Found with Stathead. See Full Results.
Generated 10/14/2026.

Career:

https://www.sports-reference.com/stathead/tiny/hSZVv

For combined seasons, At least 5000 Plate Appearances, Played at least 75% of games at C, Playing for NYY, in the regular season, requiring Home Runs >= 0 and Adjusted OPS+ >= 100, sorted by descending Adjusted OPS+.

Rk	Player	OPS+	HR	From	To	Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	1B	2B	3B	RBI	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB	Pos
1	Bill Dickey	127	202	1928	1946	21-39	1789	7065	6300	930	1969	1352	343	72	1209	678	289	.313	.382	.486	.868	3062	2H
2	Yogi Berra	125	358	1946	1963	21-38	2116	8355	7546	1174	2148	1420	321	49	1430	704	411	.285	.348	.483	.830	3641	2H79/35
3	Jorge Posada	121	275	1995	2011	24-40	1829	7150	6092	900	1664	1000	379	10	1065	936	1453	.273	.374	.474	.848	2888	2DH3/4
4	Thurman Munson	116	113	1969	1979	22-32	1423	5905	5344	696	1558	1184	229	32	701	438	571	.292	.346	.410	.756	2190	*2DH9/375
5	Elston Howard	110	161	1955	1967	26-38	1492	5487	5044	588	1405	983	211	50	733	342	717	.279	.324	.436	.760	2199	27H39

Provided by Stathead: Found with Stathead. See Full Results.
Generated 10/14/2026.

***   The End   ***