WAR between no school and new school: cease fire. You really smart guys need to educate the rest of us. This is yet another reason field managers should not be former players and why Brian Kenny should stop badgering former players like Mark DeRosa on MLB Network about stuff like wRC+.
I wrote this post because I recently stumbled onto this:
My Answer to “I Don’t Like How Complicated WAR Is and How It Is Constantly Changing.” “WAR is Like GDP for Baseball”
Posted by admin on March 29, 2013
Be sure to read the comments.
Here's some stuff I've written on it:
War on WAR.
I’m a smart guy. I understand baseball and really enjoy the numbers, even those on the uniforms. I like playing with the numbers. However, my math skills are largely confined to arithmetic. I am not a statistician or operations research person. Those are the really smart guys who have come up with the new stuff in recent years. So declaring war on them or their concepts is useless for me. I need to confine my concerns to common sense things.
There are two things about WAR for non-pitchers that should be examined:
1. WAR is a total, not an average
2. defensive WAR, more properly called fielding WAR, is suspect. The more the really smart guys delve into fielding stats in general the more they see a need to develop more methods of measurement.
Willie Mays and NL CF WAR Fielding Runs 1951-1968 Thursday, April 26, 2012
WAR 2.0: WAR Upgraded on Baseball-Reference.com Saturday, May 5, 2012
Analytics, Big Data, (garbage in, garbage out) Monday, March 4, 2013
WAR may be fading. Wednesday, November 13, 2013
wRC+ v. OPS+: top 25 in 2013 Tuesday, December 3, 2013
wRC+ is the new rage and supposedly more accurate. OPS+ is easier to find and easier to understand.
wRC+ v. OPS+ top 25 career. Wednesday, December 4, 2013
Tag: Willie Mays