Why not? Sal Fasano meets at least half of the criteria.
Jeff Pearlman of ESPN.com said of Fasano: "When I think of Sal Fasano, however, I think of greatness. Not of Willie Mays or Ted Williams greatness, but of a uniquely excellent human being who, were class and decency the most valued standards of a career, would be the easiest Hall of Fame inductee of all time."
In eleven major league seasons as a backup catcher Fasano is deficient on the two stats criteria but apparently he crushes the four character criteria.
Hall of Lists. Monday, December 21, 2015
Dan Okrent: ignore integrity, sportsmanship, character for Hall of Fame. Argh! Just kill the Hall of Fame. Thursday, December 17, 2015
Who said that Brian Kenny, Jay Jaffe, etc. have the option of ignoring character as a Hall of Fame criteria? Wednesday, July 22, 2015
Hall of Fame criteria: 66% about character, which is all but ignored. Tuesday, January 6, 2015