Best all time career outfield: Yankees Ruth, DiMaggio, Mantle v. Giants Ott, Mays, Bonds.

I initially figured it must be the Yankees: Ruth, DiMaggio, Mantle listed chronically. But then I thought that the Giants should be compared: Ott, Mays, Bonds also listed chronically.

I used OPS+ and WAR, each weighted by PA for those teams and for the outfield, which was only applied to Mantle: his final two seasons playing first base were omitted. Bonds had only 172 PA as Designated Hitter (DH) and that was ignored.

	OPS+	OPS+%	PA	PA%
Yankees	Yankees	Yankees	Yankees	Yankees
Ruth	209	74.89	9,203	35.83%
DiMaggio	155	46.30	7,672	29.87%
Mantle	175	60.03	8,810	34.30%
Total		181.21	25,685	100.00%
	WAR	WAR%		PA%
Yankees	Yankees	Yankees	Yankees	Yankees
Ruth	142.8	51.17		35.83%
DiMaggio	79.1	23.63		29.87%
Mantle	103.6	35.53		34.30%
Total		110.33		100.00%

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

	OPS+	OPS+%	PA	PA%
Giants	Giants	Giants	Giants	Giants
Ott	155	55.46	11,347	35.78%
Mays	157	59.49	12,016	37.89%
Bonds	199	52.40	8,351	26.33%
Total		167.34	31,714	100.00%
	WAR	WAR%		PA%
Giants	Giants	Giants		Giants
Ott	111.0	39.71		35.78%
Mays	154.6	58.58		37.89%
Bonds	112.5	29.62		26.33%
Total		127.91		100.00%

They split.

Yanks won OPS+ 181 to 167, largely because of Ruth.

Giants won WAR 128 to 110, largely because of Mays.