All time Yankee infielders (not first base) career.

MVP:
1942 Joe Gordon
1950 Phil Rizzuto
2005 Alex Rodriguez
2007 Alex Rodriguez

1903 to 2018 played at least 75% of games at 2B, 3B or SS

At least 3000 plate appearances, sorted by greatest WAR Position Players:

Rk	Player	WAR/pos	OPS+	HR	PA	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	RBI	BB	IBB	SO	HBP	SH	SF	GDP	SB	CS	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	Pos
1	Derek Jeter	72.4	115	260	12602	1995	2014	21-40	2747	11195	1923	3465	544	66	1311	1082	39	1840	170	97	58	287	358	97	.310	.377	.440	.817	*6/DH
2	Alex Rodriguez	54.2	136	351	6520	2004	2016	28-40	1509	5577	1012	1580	263	9	1096	779	60	1292	104	0	60	151	152	30	.283	.378	.523	.900	*5D/H63
3	Willie Randolph	54.0	105	48	7464	1976	1988	21-33	1694	6303	1027	1731	259	58	549	1005	29	512	28	75	54	171	251	82	.275	.374	.357	.731	*4/HD
4	Tony Lazzeri	48.3	120	169	7069	1926	1937	22-33	1659	6094	952	1784	327	115	1157	830		821	19	115			147	79	.293	.379	.467	.847	*45/6H37
5	Robinson Cano	45.5	126	204	5791	2005	2013	22-30	1374	5336	799	1649	375	28	822	350	65	689	54	10	41	171	38	28	.309	.355	.504	.860	*4/DH6
6	Graig Nettles	44.4	114	250	6248	1973	1983	28-38	1535	5519	750	1396	202	20	834	627	55	739	31	8	62	115	18	25	.253	.329	.433	.762	*5/HD6
7	Phil Rizzuto	40.8	93	38	6719	1941	1956	23-38	1661	5816	877	1588	239	62	563	651	35	398	49	193	2	107	149	58	.273	.351	.355	.706	*6/H4
8	Gil McDougald	40.7	111	112	5398	1951	1960	23-32	1336	4676	697	1291	187	51	576	559	15	623	36	97	27	93	45	44	.276	.356	.410	.766	456/H
9	Joe Gordon	37.5	120	153	4214	1938	1946	23-31	1000	3686	596	1000	186	38	617	481	34	508	19	30		97	68	48	.271	.358	.467	.825	*4/3H6
10	Roger Peckinpaugh	32.0	93	36	5262	1913	1921	22-30	1219	4555	670	1170	174	53	428	508		457	16	190			143	43	.257	.334	.342	.676	*6/H
11	Snuffy Stirnweiss	27.7	108	27	3800	1943	1950	24-31	884	3281	562	899	140	66	253	468	10	373	6	45		64	130	52	.274	.366	.382	.747	*4/56H
12	Frankie Crosetti	23.9	83	98	7268	1932	1948	21-37	1683	6277	1006	1541	260	65	649	792	10	799	114	90		59	113	62	.245	.341	.354	.695	*65/H4
13	Red Rolfe	23.5	99	69	5406	1931	1942	22-33	1175	4827	942	1394	257	67	497	526	0	335	10	42		14	44	20	.289	.360	.413	.773	*5/6H
14	Clete Boyer	19.6	86	95	4037	1959	1966	22-29	1068	3658	434	882	140	25	393	297	51	608	15	27	38	81	27	12	.241	.298	.371	.669	*56/H4
15	Tony Kubek	18.4	85	57	4493	1957	1965	21-29	1092	4167	522	1109	178	30	373	217	24	441	13	71	26	62	29	23	.266	.303	.364	.667	*6/7H58943
16	Horace Clarke	16.0	84	27	5143	1965	1974	25-34	1230	4723	543	1213	149	23	300	357	18	356	11	28	24	77	151	58	.257	.309	.315	.624	*4/H65D
17	Aaron Ward	11.7	84	45	3582	1917	1926	20-29	908	3139	382	840	133	46	390	275		399	23	128			30	33	.268	.331	.382	.713	*45/H6389
18	Bobby Richardson	8.2	77	34	5780	1955	1966	19-30	1412	5386	643	1432	196	37	390	262	20	243	7	98	30	100	73	48	.266	.299	.335	.634	*4/H56
19	Joe Dugan	7.2	82	22	3325	1922	1928	25-31	785	3043	426	871	147	27	316	156		183	22	107			12	16	.286	.326	.374	.700	*5/H4

OPS+ >=100:

Rk	Player	WAR/pos	OPS+ ▼	HR	PA	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	RBI	BB	IBB	SO	HBP	SH	SF	GDP	SB	CS	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	Pos
1	Alex Rodriguez	54.2	136	351	6520	2004	2016	28-40	1509	5577	1012	1580	263	9	1096	779	60	1292	104	0	60	151	152	30	.283	.378	.523	.900	*5D/H63
2	Robinson Cano	45.5	126	204	5791	2005	2013	22-30	1374	5336	799	1649	375	28	822	350	65	689	54	10	41	171	38	28	.309	.355	.504	.860	*4/DH6
3	Tony Lazzeri	48.3	120	169	7069	1926	1937	22-33	1659	6094	952	1784	327	115	1157	830		821	19	115			147	79	.293	.379	.467	.847	*45/6H37
4	Joe Gordon	37.5	120	153	4214	1938	1946	23-31	1000	3686	596	1000	186	38	617	481	34	508	19	30		97	68	48	.271	.358	.467	.825	*4/3H6
5	Derek Jeter	72.4	115	260	12602	1995	2014	21-40	2747	11195	1923	3465	544	66	1311	1082	39	1840	170	97	58	287	358	97	.310	.377	.440	.817	*6/DH
6	Graig Nettles	44.4	114	250	6248	1973	1983	28-38	1535	5519	750	1396	202	20	834	627	55	739	31	8	62	115	18	25	.253	.329	.433	.762	*5/HD6
7	Gil McDougald	40.7	111	112	5398	1951	1960	23-32	1336	4676	697	1291	187	51	576	559	15	623	36	97	27	93	45	44	.276	.356	.410	.766	456/H
8	Snuffy Stirnweiss	27.7	108	27	3800	1943	1950	24-31	884	3281	562	899	140	66	253	468	10	373	6	45		64	130	52	.274	.366	.382	.747	*4/56H
9	Willie Randolph	54.0	105	48	7464	1976	1988	21-33	1694	6303	1027	1731	259	58	549	1005	29	512	28	75	54	171	251	82	.275	.374	.357	.731	*4/HD

Jeter is the only one with more than 10,000 PA. At least 5,000 PA:

Rk	Player	WAR/pos	OPS+	HR	PA ▼	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	RBI	BB	IBB	SO	HBP	SH	SF	GDP	SB	CS	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	Pos
1	Derek Jeter	72.4	115	260	12602	1995	2014	21-40	2747	11195	1923	3465	544	66	1311	1082	39	1840	170	97	58	287	358	97	.310	.377	.440	.817	*6/DH
2	Willie Randolph	54.0	105	48	7464	1976	1988	21-33	1694	6303	1027	1731	259	58	549	1005	29	512	28	75	54	171	251	82	.275	.374	.357	.731	*4/HD
3	Frankie Crosetti	23.9	83	98	7268	1932	1948	21-37	1683	6277	1006	1541	260	65	649	792	10	799	114	90		59	113	62	.245	.341	.354	.695	*65/H4
4	Tony Lazzeri	48.3	120	169	7069	1926	1937	22-33	1659	6094	952	1784	327	115	1157	830		821	19	115			147	79	.293	.379	.467	.847	*45/6H37
5	Phil Rizzuto	40.8	93	38	6719	1941	1956	23-38	1661	5816	877	1588	239	62	563	651	35	398	49	193	2	107	149	58	.273	.351	.355	.706	*6/H4
6	Alex Rodriguez	54.2	136	351	6520	2004	2016	28-40	1509	5577	1012	1580	263	9	1096	779	60	1292	104	0	60	151	152	30	.283	.378	.523	.900	*5D/H63
7	Graig Nettles	44.4	114	250	6248	1973	1983	28-38	1535	5519	750	1396	202	20	834	627	55	739	31	8	62	115	18	25	.253	.329	.433	.762	*5/HD6
8	Robinson Cano	45.5	126	204	5791	2005	2013	22-30	1374	5336	799	1649	375	28	822	350	65	689	54	10	41	171	38	28	.309	.355	.504	.860	*4/DH6
9	Bobby Richardson	8.2	77	34	5780	1955	1966	19-30	1412	5386	643	1432	196	37	390	262	20	243	7	98	30	100	73	48	.266	.299	.335	.634	*4/H56
10	Red Rolfe	23.5	99	69	5406	1931	1942	22-33	1175	4827	942	1394	257	67	497	526	0	335	10	42		14	44	20	.289	.360	.413	.773	*5/6H
11	Gil McDougald	40.7	111	112	5398	1951	1960	23-32	1336	4676	697	1291	187	51	576	559	15	623	36	97	27	93	45	44	.276	.356	.410	.766	456/H
12	Roger Peckinpaugh	32.0	93	36	5262	1913	1921	22-30	1219	4555	670	1170	174	53	428	508		457	16	190			143	43	.257	.334	.342	.676	*6/H
13	Horace Clarke	16.0	84	27	5143	1965	1974	25-34	1230	4723	543	1213	149	23	300	357	18	356	11	28	24	77	151	58	.257

At least 100 home runs:

Rk	Player	WAR/pos	OPS+	HR ▼	PA	From	To	Age	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	RBI	BB	IBB	SO	HBP	SH	SF	GDP	SB	CS	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	Pos
1	Alex Rodriguez	54.2	136	351	6520	2004	2016	28-40	1509	5577	1012	1580	263	9	1096	779	60	1292	104	0	60	151	152	30	.283	.378	.523	.900	*5D/H63
2	Derek Jeter	72.4	115	260	12602	1995	2014	21-40	2747	11195	1923	3465	544	66	1311	1082	39	1840	170	97	58	287	358	97	.310	.377	.440	.817	*6/DH
3	Graig Nettles	44.4	114	250	6248	1973	1983	28-38	1535	5519	750	1396	202	20	834	627	55	739	31	8	62	115	18	25	.253	.329	.433	.762	*5/HD6
4	Robinson Cano	45.5	126	204	5791	2005	2013	22-30	1374	5336	799	1649	375	28	822	350	65	689	54	10	41	171	38	28	.309	.355	.504	.860	*4/DH6
5	Tony Lazzeri	48.3	120	169	7069	1926	1937	22-33	1659	6094	952	1784	327	115	1157	830		821	19	115			147	79	.293	.379	.467	.847	*45/6H37
6	Joe Gordon	37.5	120	153	4214	1938	1946	23-31	1000	3686	596	1000	186	38	617	481	34	508	19	30		97	68	48	.271	.358	.467	.825	*4/3H6
7	Gil McDougald	40.7	111	112	5398	1951	1960	23-32	1336	4676	697	1291	187	51	576	559	15	623	36	97	27	93	45	44	.276	.356	.410	.766	456/H

Gil McDougald is number 8 in WAR, 7 in OPS+, 7 in Home Runs.

Gil McDougald for the Hall of Fame. Hey, higher WAR than Harold Baines in half the time. Friday, January 11, 2019

Gil McDougald is a good test case for those who want to elect all sorts of former players to the Hall of Fame. Cooperstown justice as they say on MLB Network.
________________________________