Aaron Judge joins 3 other Yankees with 3 MVP: DiMaggio, Berra, Mantle.

Aaron Judge

Position: Rightfielder

Bats: Right  •  Throws: Right

6-7, 282lb (201cm, 127kg)

Team: New York Yankees (majors)

Born: April 26, 1992 (Age: 33-202d) in Linden, CA us

New York Yankees have been voted American League (AL) Most Valuable Player (MVP) 22 times through 2025 since the current award started in 1931. Here they are in year order and with their age on October 1 of that year.

Rk	birthdate	MVPdate	Years	Days	Season	Player	WAR	oWAR	dWAR	OPS+	HR	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS
1	7/19/1903	10/1/1936	33	74	1936	Lou Gehrig	9.7	9.8	-.6	190	49	.354	.478	.696	1.174
2	11/25/1914	10/1/1939	24	310	1939	Joe DiMaggio	8.3	7.2	1.0	184	30	.381	.448	.671	1.119
3	11/25/1914	10/1/1941	26	310	1941	Joe DiMaggio	9.3	8.5	.7	185	30	.357	.440	.643	1.083
4	2/18/1915	10/1/1942	27	225	1942	Joe Gordon	7.7	6.0	2.5	155	18	.322	.409	.491	.900
5	11/25/1914	10/1/1947	32	310	1947	Joe DiMaggio	4.7	5.6	-1.0	154	20	.315	.391	.522	.913
6	9/25/1917	10/1/1950	33	6	1950	Phil Rizzuto	6.8	5.7	2.1	122	7	.324	.418	.439	.857
7	5/12/1925	10/1/1951	26	142	1951	Yogi Berra	5.3	4.2	1.4	130	27	.294	.350	.492	.842
8	5/12/1925	10/1/1954	29	142	1954	Yogi Berra	5.3	5.5	.5	137	22	.307	.367	.488	.855
9	5/12/1925	10/1/1955	30	142	1955	Yogi Berra	4.5	4.1	1.0	120	27	.272	.349	.470	.819
10	10/20/1931	10/1/1956	24	347	1956	Mickey Mantle	11.3	10.7	.5	210	52	.353	.464	.705	1.169
11	10/20/1931	10/1/1957	25	347	1957	Mickey Mantle	11.3	11.3	-.1	221	34	.365	.512	.665	1.177
12	9/10/1934	10/1/1960	26	21	1960	Roger Maris	7.5	5.7	1.4	160	39	.283	.371	.581	.952
13	9/10/1934	10/1/1961	27	21	1961	Roger Maris	6.9	7.0	-.7	167	61	.269	.372	.620	.993
14	10/20/1931	10/1/1962	30	347	1962	Mickey Mantle	6.0	7.7	-1.8	195	30	.321	.486	.605	1.091
15	2/23/1929	10/1/1963	34	220	1963	Elston Howard	5.2	4.8	1.3	141	28	.287	.342	.528	.869
16	6/7/1947	10/1/1976	29	116	1976	Thurman Munson	5.3	5.4	.7	126	17	.302	.337	.432	.769
17	4/20/1961	10/1/1985	24	164	1985	Don Mattingly	6.4	6.5	-.9	156	35	.324	.371	.567	.939
18	7/27/1975	10/1/2005	30	66	2005	Álex Rodríguez	9.4	9.4	.4	173	48	.321	.421	.610	1.031
19	7/27/1975	10/1/2007	32	66	2007	Álex Rodríguez	9.4	9.5	.2	176	54	.314	.422	.645	1.067
20	4/26/1992	10/1/2022	30	158	2022	Aaron Judge	10.8	10.3	.3	210	62	.311	.425	.686	1.111
21	4/26/1992	10/1/2024	32	158	2024	Aaron Judge	10.8	11.7	-.9	225	58	.322	.458	.701	1.159
22	4/26/1992	10/1/2025	33	158	2025	Aaron Judge	9.7	9.4	-.5	215	53	.331	.457	.688	1.144
Rk	birthdate	MVPdate	Years	Days	Season	Player	WAR	oWAR	dWAR	OPS+	HR	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS
						max	11.3	11.7	2.5	225.0	62	.381	.512	.705	1.177
						min	4.5	4.1	-1.8	120.0	7	.269	.337	.432	.769

Don Mattingly was the youngest and Elston Howard was the oldest.

Here they are sorted by age in the MVP season:

Rk	birthdate	MVPdate	Years	Days	Season	Player	WAR	oWAR	dWAR	OPS+	HR	BA	OBP	SLG
17	4/20/1961	10/1/1985	24	164	1985	Don Mattingly	6.4	6.5	-.9	156	35	.324	.371	.567
2	11/25/1914	10/1/1939	24	310	1939	Joe DiMaggio	8.3	7.2	1.0	184	30	.381	.448	.671
10	10/20/1931	10/1/1956	24	347	1956	Mickey Mantle	11.3	10.7	.5	210	52	.353	.464	.705
11	10/20/1931	10/1/1957	25	347	1957	Mickey Mantle	11.3	11.3	-.1	221	34	.365	.512	.665
12	9/10/1934	10/1/1960	26	21	1960	Roger Maris	7.5	5.7	1.4	160	39	.283	.371	.581
7	5/12/1925	10/1/1951	26	142	1951	Yogi Berra	5.3	4.2	1.4	130	27	.294	.350	.492
3	11/25/1914	10/1/1941	26	310	1941	Joe DiMaggio	9.3	8.5	.7	185	30	.357	.440	.643
13	9/10/1934	10/1/1961	27	21	1961	Roger Maris	6.9	7.0	-.7	167	61	.269	.372	.620
4	2/18/1915	10/1/1942	27	225	1942	Joe Gordon	7.7	6.0	2.5	155	18	.322	.409	.491
16	6/7/1947	10/1/1976	29	116	1976	Thurman Munson	5.3	5.4	.7	126	17	.302	.337	.432
8	5/12/1925	10/1/1954	29	142	1954	Yogi Berra	5.3	5.5	.5	137	22	.307	.367	.488
18	7/27/1975	10/1/2005	30	66	2005	Álex Rodríguez	9.4	9.4	.4	173	48	.321	.421	.610
9	5/12/1925	10/1/1955	30	142	1955	Yogi Berra	4.5	4.1	1.0	120	27	.272	.349	.470
20	4/26/1992	10/1/2022	30	158	2022	Aaron Judge	10.8	10.3	.3	210	62	.311	.425	.686
14	10/20/1931	10/1/1962	30	347	1962	Mickey Mantle	6.0	7.7	-1.8	195	30	.321	.486	.605
19	7/27/1975	10/1/2007	32	66	2007	Álex Rodríguez	9.4	9.5	.2	176	54	.314	.422	.645
21	4/26/1992	10/1/2024	32	158	2024	Aaron Judge	10.8	11.7	-.9	225	58	.322	.458	.701
5	11/25/1914	10/1/1947	32	310	1947	Joe DiMaggio	4.7	5.6	-1.0	154	20	.315	.391	.522
6	9/25/1917	10/1/1950	33	6	1950	Phil Rizzuto	6.8	5.7	2.1	122	7	.324	.418	.439
1	7/19/1903	10/1/1936	33	74	1936	Lou Gehrig	9.7	9.8	-.6	190	49	.354	.478	.696
22	4/26/1992	10/1/2025	33	158	2025	Aaron Judge	9.7	9.4	-.5	215	53	.331	.457	.688
15	2/23/1929	10/1/1963	34	220	1963	Elston Howard	5.2	4.8	1.3	141	28	.287	.342	.528
Rk	birthdate	MVPdate	Years	Days	Season	Player	WAR	oWAR	dWAR	OPS+	HR	BA	OBP	SLG
						max	11.3	11.7	2.5	225.0	62	.381	.512	.705
						min	4.5	4.1	-1.8	120.0	7	.269	.337	.432

The most recent winner, Aaron Judge in 2025, is the second oldest.

Let's look at the four Yankees to win MVP three times each.

Rk	birthdate	MVPdate	Years	Days	Season	Player	WAR	oWAR	dWAR	OPS+	HR	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS
2	11/25/1914	10/1/1939	24	310	1939	Joe DiMaggio	8.3	7.2	1.0	184	30	.381	.448	.671	1.119
3	11/25/1914	10/1/1941	26	310	1941	Joe DiMaggio	9.3	8.5	.7	185	30	.357	.440	.643	1.083
5	11/25/1914	10/1/1947	32	310	1947	Joe DiMaggio	4.7	5.6	-1.0	154	20	.315	.391	.522	.913
7	5/12/1925	10/1/1951	26	142	1951	Yogi Berra	5.3	4.2	1.4	130	27	.294	.350	.492	.842
8	5/12/1925	10/1/1954	29	142	1954	Yogi Berra	5.3	5.5	.5	137	22	.307	.367	.488	.855
9	5/12/1925	10/1/1955	30	142	1955	Yogi Berra	4.5	4.1	1.0	120	27	.272	.349	.470	.819
10	10/20/1931	10/1/1956	24	347	1956	Mickey Mantle	11.3	10.7	.5	210	52	.353	.464	.705	1.169
11	10/20/1931	10/1/1957	25	347	1957	Mickey Mantle	11.3	11.3	-.1	221	34	.365	.512	.665	1.177
14	10/20/1931	10/1/1962	30	347	1962	Mickey Mantle	6.0	7.7	-1.8	195	30	.321	.486	.605	1.091
20	4/26/1992	10/1/2022	30	158	2022	Aaron Judge	10.8	10.3	.3	210	62	.311	.425	.686	1.111
21	4/26/1992	10/1/2024	32	158	2024	Aaron Judge	10.8	11.7	-.9	225	58	.322	.458	.701	1.159
22	4/26/1992	10/1/2025	33	158	2025	Aaron Judge	9.7	9.4	-.5	215	53	.331	.457	.688	1.144
Rk	birthdate	MVPdate	Years	Days	Season	Player	WAR	oWAR	dWAR	OPS+	HR	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS

DiMaggio was the youngest to win his first.

Berra was the youngest to win his third.

Judge was the oldest to win his first.

Judge was the oldest to win his third.

***   The End   ***