Saturday, June 18, 2022

Aaron Judge batted leadoff six times in 2022 ... so far. Shouldn't he bat third?

It seems counterintuitive. In 2022 Yankee outfielder Aaron Judge is the big bopper in the American League (AL). OPS+ 201. His Yankees are 48-16. Judge leads MLB with 25 home runs (HR) in 237 at bats (AB). Judge could break the season home run record for the Yankees and AL: 61 by Roger Maris in 1961 in the first 162 game schedule; 60 by Babe Ruth in 1927 in the 154 game schedule. Both the 1961 and 1927 Yankees played a tie game, so add that: 163 and 155 games.

60 Home Runs in 154 games: Ruth yes. Maris no. Bonds, McGwire, Sosa? Monday, June 12, 2017

Photo of Roger Maris

Roger Maris

Position: Rightfielder

Bats: Left  •  Throws: Right

6-0197lb (183cm, 89kg)

Born: September 101934 in Hibbing, MN us

Died: December 141985 (Aged 51-095d) in Houston, TX






2022 is the first full season of the universal designated hitter (DH). So the number 9 hitter is not the pitcher as it was in 1961 and 1927. But that doesn't mean the #9 is a good hitter. Despite the Yankees leading in HR and Runs, they have three weak hitters: catcher, shortstop, one outfield spot. That could come home to haunt them in the tournament.

The problem with having your best hitter leading off and not hitting third is that his first time up he has no teammates on base. While he cannot have the bases full, batting third ensures that he bats in the first inning.

Batting leadoff gets him a few more plate appearances (PA) during the season. But are they enough to justify his batting with fewer base runners? Remember, he's batting behind the bottom of the order.

Yankee manager Aaron Boone has batted Judge mostly #2.

SplitGGSPAABRH2B3BHRRBISBCSBBSOBAOBPSLGOPSTBGDPHBPSHSFIBBROEBAbiptOPS+sOPS+
Batting 1st6629247900361035.375.414.7501.16418000210.333119224
Batting 2nd535323520447631002243202858.309.389.6811.070139700250.325102170
Batting 3rd22980200001014.250.333.250.5832100000.5002360
Batting 8th10110000000000.000.000.000.0000000000.000-100-100

Here's details on the six games in which Aaron Judge batted leadoff:

5/26/2022at Tam5/27/2022at Tam6/4/2022Det6/11/2022Cubs6/12/2022Cubs6/17/2022at Tor
1Aaron JudgeCF1Aaron JudgeCF1Aaron JudgeCF1Aaron JudgeDH1Aaron JudgeCF1Aaron JudgeCF
2Anthony Rizzo1B2Anthony Rizzo1B2Josh Donaldson3B2Josh Donaldson3B2Anthony Rizzo1B2Josh DonaldsonDH
3Gleyber Torres2B3Gleyber Torres2B3Anthony Rizzo1B3Anthony Rizzo1B3Giancarlo StantonDH3Anthony Rizzo1B
4Miguel AndujarLF4Miguel AndujarLF4Giancarlo StantonDH4Giancarlo StantonRF4DJ LeMahieu2B4Giancarlo StantonRF
5Joey GalloRF5Matt CarpenterDH5Gleyber Torres2B5Gleyber Torres2B5Matt Carpenter3B5DJ LeMahieu3B
6Isiah Kiner-FalefaSS6Isiah Kiner-FalefaSS6Joey GalloRF6Aaron HicksCF6Isiah Kiner-FalefaSS6Gleyber Torres2B
7Jose TrevinoC7Joey GalloRF7Isiah Kiner-FalefaSS7Isiah Kiner-FalefaSS7Marwin GonzalezLF7Joey GalloLF
8Matt CarpenterDH8Kyle HigashiokaC8Kyle HigashiokaC8Jose TrevinoC8Kyle HigashiokaC8Isiah Kiner-FalefaSS
9Marwin Gonzalez3B9Marwin Gonzalez3B9Aaron HicksLF9Joey GalloLF9Joey GalloRF9Kyle HigashiokaC
opp starter:opp starter:opp starter:opp starter:opp starter:opp starter:
Ryan YarbroughJeffrey SpringsBeau BrieskeMatt SwarmerKeegan ThompsonRoss Stripling
RightyLeftyRightyRightyRightyRighty
score7-22-03-08-018-412-3
1 for 3, BB0 for 41 for 3, BB, HR2 for 3, 2 HRSIX HR3 for 62 for 5, BB

The Yankees won all six games. The #9 batter varies, so Judge is not "protecting" anyone in particular. The #2 batter has been only two teammates: Rizzo and Donaldson, three times each.

Batting in the next lineup:
Maris:
most of the time Mickey Mantle (54 HR in 1961, second in MLB); Lopez for #60, Berra for #61

Ruth: all the time Lou Gehrig (47 HR in 1927, second in MLB)

Shouldn't Judge at least have Giancarlo Stanton (59 HR in 2017 with the Marlins)?

So, what do you think?

No comments: