Hall of Fame center fielders: Mays, Mantle, Cobb... yes. Edmunds, Lynn, Williams no.

Two lists, sorted on OPS+, of center fielders:

17 in Hall of Fame, all the way down to Lloyd Waner.

72 not in Hall of Fame, McGee and Flood at the bottom.

For combined seasons, Playing in the AL or NL, Played at CF at least 50% of games, a member of the Hall of Fame, in the regular season, sorted by descending Adjusted OPS+.

17 center fielders inducted. Fewest PA: Wilson 5,557.

For combined seasons, Playing in the AL or NL, Played at CF at least 50% of games, is not a member of the Hall of Fame, in the regular season, requiring Plate Appearances PA >= 5000 and Adjusted OPS+ >= 100, sorted by descending Adjusted OPS+.

72 center fielders found. Trout and McCutchen are still active. HoF Lloyd Waner would not make this list.

Rk	Player	OPS+	From	To	Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	1B	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB
1	Mickey Mantle	172	1951	1968	19-36	2,401	9,910	8,102	1,676	2,415	1,463	344	72	536	1,509	153	38	1,733	1,710	.298	.421	.557	.977	4,511
2	Ty Cobb	168	1905	1928	18-41	3,034	13,103	11,440	2,245	4,189	3,053	724	295	117	1,944	897	215	1,249	680	.366	.433	.512	.944	5,854
3	Tris Speaker	158	1907	1928	19-40	2,789	12,020	10,195	1,882	3,514	2,383	792	222	117	1,531	436	158	1,381	393	.345	.428	.500	.928	5,101
4	Willie Mays	156	1951	1973	20-42	2,992	12,497	10,881	2,062	3,283	1,960	523	140	660	1,903	338	103	1,464	1,526	.302	.384	.557	.941	6,066
5	Joe DiMaggio	155	1936	1951	21-36	1,736	7,672	6,821	1,390	2,214	1,333	389	131	361	1,537	30	9	790	369	.325	.398	.579	.977	3,948
6	Hack Wilson	144	1923	1934	23-34	1,348	5,557	4,760	884	1,461	884	266	67	244	1,063	52	34	674	713	.307	.395	.545	.940	2,593
7	Billy Hamilton	143	1890	1901	24-35	1,422	6,837	5,620	1,532	1,969	1,632	221	79	37	654	784		1,098	308	.350	.462	.438	.900	2,459
8	Duke Snider	140	1947	1964	20-37	2,143	8,237	7,161	1,259	2,116	1,266	358	85	407	1,333	99	73	971	1,237	.295	.380	.540	.919	3,865
9	Larry Doby	136	1947	1959	23-35	1,533	6,302	5,348	960	1,515	967	243	52	253	970	47	36	871	1,011	.283	.386	.490	.876	2,621
10	Ken Griffey Jr.	136	1989	2010	19-40	2,671	11,304	9,801	1,662	2,781	1,589	524	38	630	1,836	184	69	1,312	1,779	.284	.370	.538	.907	5,271
11	Earl Averill	133	1929	1941	27-39	1,669	7,221	6,353	1,224	2,019	1,252	401	128	238	1,164	70	58	774	518	.318	.395	.534	.928	3,390
12	Edd Roush	127	1913	1931	20-38	1,748	7,352	6,646	1,000	2,158	1,616	311	167	64	891	228	134	440	215	.325	.371	.451	.821	2,995
13	Earle Combs	125	1924	1935	25-36	1,455	6,514	5,746	1,186	1,866	1,345	309	154	58	633	98	70	670	278	.325	.397	.462	.859	2,657
14	Kirby Puckett	124	1984	1995	24-35	1,783	7,831	7,244	1,071	2,304	1,626	414	57	207	1,085	134	76	450	965	.318	.360	.477	.837	3,453
15	Richie Ashburn	111	1948	1962	21-35	2,189	9,737	8,365	1,322	2,574	2,119	317	109	29	586	234	117	1,198	571	.308	.396	.382	.778	3,196
16	Max Carey	108	1910	1929	20-39	2,476	10,772	9,363	1,545	2,665	2,017	419	159	70	802	738	127	1,040	695	.285	.361	.386	.747	3,612
17	Lloyd Waner	99	1927	1945	21-39	1,993	8,337	7,772	1,201	2,459	2,033	281	118	27	598	67	60	420	173	.316	.353	.393	.747	3,057
Rk	Player	OPS+	From	To	Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	1B	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB
1	Mike Trout	174	2011	2023	19-31	1,488	6,517	5,398	1,106	1,623	893	310	52	368	940	206	37	964	1,457	.301	.412	.582	.994	3,141
2	Wally Berger	138	1930	1940	24-34	1,350	5,666	5,163	809	1,550	950	299	59	242	898	36	41	435	693	.300	.359	.522	.881	2,693
3	George Gore	136	1879	1892	25-38	1,217	5,625	4,958	1,195	1,485	1,127	236	86	36	563	142		640	309	.300	.383	.404	.786	2,001
4	Paul Hines	133	1876	1890	21-35	1,427	6,418	6,047	1,058	1,823	1,327	361	79	56	720	147		345	288	.301	.342	.415	.757	2,510
5	Jim Edmonds	132	1993	2010	23-40	2,011	7,980	6,858	1,251	1,949	1,094	437	25	393	1,199	67	50	998	1,729	.284	.376	.527	.903	3,615
6	Fred Lynn	129	1974	1990	22-38	1,969	7,923	6,925	1,063	1,960	1,223	388	43	306	1,111	72	54	857	1,116	.283	.360	.484	.845	3,352
7	Jim Wynn	129	1963	1977	21-35	1,920	8,011	6,653	1,105	1,665	1,050	285	39	291	964	225	101	1,224	1,427	.250	.366	.436	.802	2,901
8	Andrew McCutchen	128	2009	2023	22-36	1,969	8,484	7,296	1,156	2,018	1,269	403	49	297	1,030	214	87	1,032	1,606	.277	.369	.467	.837	3,410
9	Ellis Burks	126	1987	2004	22-39	2,000	8,177	7,232	1,253	2,107	1,290	402	63	352	1,206	181	84	793	1,340	.291	.363	.510	.874	3,691
10	Cy Williams	125	1912	1930	24-42	2,002	7,727	6,780	1,024	1,981	1,350	306	74	251	1,005	115	99	690	721	.292	.365	.470	.835	3,188
11	Rick Monday	125	1966	1984	20-38	1,986	7,162	6,136	950	1,619	1,066	248	64	241	775	98	91	924	1,513	.264	.361	.443	.804	2,718
12	Eric Davis	125	1984	2001	22-39	1,626	6,147	5,321	938	1,430	883	239	26	282	934	349	66	740	1,398	.269	.359	.482	.841	2,567
13	Bernie Williams	125	1991	2006	22-37	2,076	9,053	7,869	1,366	2,336	1,545	449	55	287	1,257	147	87	1,069	1,212	.297	.381	.477	.858	3,756
14	Roy Thomas	124	1899	1911	25-37	1,470	6,602	5,296	1,011	1,537	1,377	100	53	7	299	244		1,042	521	.290	.413	.333	.747	1,764
15	Ginger Beaumont	123	1899	1910	22-33	1,463	6,313	5,660	955	1,759	1,456	182	82	39	617	254		425	314	.311	.362	.393	.755	2,222
16	César Cedeño	123	1970	1986	19-35	2,006	8,133	7,310	1,084	2,087	1,392	436	60	199	976	550	179	664	938	.285	.347	.443	.790	3,240
17	Ray Lankford	123	1990	2004	23-37	1,701	6,675	5,747	968	1,561	913	356	54	238	874	258	117	828	1,550	.272	.364	.477	.840	2,739
18	Chick Stahl	122	1897	1906	24-33	1,304	5,718	5,069	858	1,546	1,173	219	118	36	622	189		470	270	.305	.369	.416	.785	2,109
19	Chet Lemon	121	1975	1990	20-35	1,988	7,874	6,868	973	1,875	1,203	396	61	215	884	58	76	749	1,024	.273	.355	.442	.797	3,038
20	George Van Haltren	120	1887	1903	21-37	1,759	7,959	7,101	1,422	2,238	1,782	264	137	55	878	473		759	429	.315	.384	.414	.798	2,941
21	Lenny Dykstra	120	1985	1996	22-33	1,278	5,282	4,559	802	1,298	893	281	43	81	404	285	72	640	503	.285	.375	.419	.793	1,908
22	Carlos Beltrán	119	1998	2017	21-40	2,586	11,031	9,768	1,582	2,725	1,647	565	78	435	1,587	312	49	1,084	1,795	.279	.350	.486	.837	4,751
23	Andy Van Slyke	119	1983	1995	22-34	1,658	6,495	5,711	835	1,562	1,014	293	91	164	792	245	59	667	1,063	.274	.349	.443	.792	2,529
24	Cy Seymour	118	1896	1913	23-40	1,529	6,227	5,686	737	1,724	1,347	229	96	52	799	222	1	354	361	.303	.347	.405	.752	2,301
25	Dwayne Murphy	115	1978	1989	23-34	1,360	5,242	4,347	648	1,069	744	139	20	166	609	100	61	747	953	.246	.356	.402	.757	1,746
26	Amos Otis	115	1967	1984	20-37	1,998	8,247	7,299	1,092	2,020	1,387	374	66	193	1,007	341	93	757	1,008	.277	.343	.425	.768	3,105
27	Tony González	114	1960	1971	23-34	1,559	5,794	5,195	690	1,485	1,087	238	57	103	615	79	61	467	706	.286	.350	.413	.764	2,146
28	Gorman Thomas	114	1973	1986	22-35	1,436	5,486	4,677	681	1,051	558	212	13	268	782	50	49	697	1,339	.225	.324	.448	.772	2,093
29	Curtis Granderson	113	2004	2019	23-38	2,057	8,306	7,236	1,217	1,800	1,015	346	95	344	937	153	50	924	1,916	.249	.337	.465	.803	3,368
30	Amos Strunk	112	1908	1924	19-35	1,512	5,828	4,999	696	1,418	1,094	213	96	15	529	185	100	573	453	.284	.359	.374	.732	1,868
31	Fielder Jones	112	1896	1908	24-36	1,776	7,914	6,738	1,179	1,919	1,617	206	75	21	631	359		816	422	.285	.368	.347	.715	2,338
32	Baby Doll Jacobson	112	1915	1927	24-36	1,472	6,078	5,507	787	1,714	1,209	328	94	83	818	86	54	355	410	.311	.357	.450	.807	2,479
33	Andruw Jones	111	1996	2012	19-35	2,196	8,664	7,599	1,204	1,933	1,080	383	36	434	1,289	152	59	891	1,748	.254	.337	.486	.823	3,690
34	Vada Pinson	111	1958	1975	19-36	2,469	10,405	9,645	1,365	2,757	1,889	485	127	256	1,169	305	122	574	1,196	.286	.327	.442	.769	4,264
35	Dom DiMaggio	111	1940	1953	23-36	1,399	6,478	5,640	1,046	1,680	1,228	308	57	87	618	100	62	750	571	.298	.383	.419	.802	2,363
36	Bobby Thomson	110	1946	1960	22-36	1,779	6,961	6,305	903	1,705	1,100	267	74	264	1,026	38	33	559	804	.270	.332	.462	.794	2,912
37	Torii Hunter	110	1997	2015	21-39	2,372	9,692	8,857	1,296	2,452	1,562	498	39	353	1,391	195	99	661	1,741	.277	.331	.461	.793	4,087
38	Brett Butler	110	1981	1997	24-40	2,213	9,545	8,180	1,359	2,375	1,913	277	131	54	578	558	257	1,129	907	.290	.377	.376	.753	3,076
39	Brady Anderson	109	1988	2002	24-38	1,834	7,737	6,499	1,062	1,661	1,046	338	67	210	761	315	100	960	1,190	.256	.362	.425	.787	2,763
40	Clyde Milan	109	1907	1922	20-35	1,982	8,339	7,359	1,004	2,100	1,738	240	105	17	617	495	109	685	407	.285	.353	.353	.706	2,601
41	Billy Hoy	109	1888	1902	26-40	1,536	7,103	6,063	1,188	1,738	1,378	218	108	34	608	498		795	284	.287	.380	.375	.755	2,274
42	Dode Paskert	108	1907	1921	25-39	1,716	7,012	6,017	868	1,613	1,215	279	77	42	577	293	60	715	784	.268	.350	.361	.711	2,172
43	Jerry Mumphrey	108	1974	1988	21-35	1,585	5,545	4,993	660	1,442	1,100	217	55	70	575	174	80	478	688	.289	.349	.396	.745	1,979
44	Dave Henderson	108	1981	1994	22-35	1,538	5,677	5,130	710	1,324	824	286	17	197	708	50	38	465	1,105	.258	.320	.436	.756	2,235
45	Kenny Lofton	107	1991	2007	24-40	2,103	9,235	8,120	1,528	2,428	1,799	383	116	130	781	622	160	945	1,016	.299	.372	.423	.794	3,433
46	Sam Chapman	107	1938	1951	22-35	1,368	5,600	4,988	754	1,329	887	210	52	180	773	41	38	562	682	.266	.342	.438	.780	2,183
47	Carl Everett	107	1993	2006	22-35	1,405	5,395	4,809	707	1,304	818	258	26	202	792	107	54	442	1,021	.271	.341	.462	.802	2,220
48	Mickey Rivers	106	1970	1984	21-35	1,468	6,027	5,629	785	1,660	1,281	247	71	61	499	267	90	266	471	.295	.327	.397	.724	2,232
49	Adam Jones	106	2006	2019	20-33	1,823	7,516	7,009	963	1,939	1,292	336	29	282	945	97	35	340	1,395	.277	.317	.454	.771	3,179
50	Ruppert Jones	106	1976	1987	21-32	1,331	5,041	4,415	643	1,103	703	215	38	147	579	143	84	534	817	.250	.330	.416	.746	1,835
51	Roberto Kelly	106	1987	2000	22-35	1,337	5,243	4,797	687	1,390	995	241	30	124	585	235	84	317	862	.290	.337	.430	.767	2,063
52	Charlie Hemphill	106	1899	1911	23-35	1,242	5,127	4,541	580	1,230	1,023	117	68	22	421	207		435	429	.271	.337	.341	.678	1,549
53	Mike Cameron	106	1995	2011	22-38	1,955	7,884	6,839	1,064	1,700	980	383	59	278	968	297	83	867	1,901	.249	.338	.444	.782	3,035
54	Willie Davis	106	1960	1979	20-39	2,429	9,822	9,174	1,217	2,561	1,846	395	138	182	1,053	398	131	418	977	.279	.311	.412	.723	3,778
55	Matty Alou	105	1960	1974	21-35	1,667	6,220	5,789	780	1,777	1,460	236	50	31	427	156	80	311	377	.307	.345	.381	.726	2,206
56	Dexter Fowler	104	2008	2021	22-35	1,460	5,902	5,040	817	1,306	844	253	82	127	517	149	68	740	1,326	.259	.358	.417	.775	2,104
57	Steve Finley	104	1989	2007	24-42	2,583	10,460	9,397	1,443	2,548	1,671	449	124	304	1,167	320	118	844	1,299	.271	.332	.442	.775	4,157
58	Sam West	104	1927	1942	22-37	1,753	6,974	6,148	934	1,838	1,315	347	101	75	838	54	56	696	540	.299	.371	.425	.796	2,612
59	Johnny Damon	104	1995	2012	21-38	2,490	10,917	9,736	1,668	2,769	1,903	522	109	235	1,139	408	103	1,003	1,257	.284	.352	.433	.785	4,214
60	Vernon Wells	104	1999	2013	20-34	1,731	7,212	6,642	930	1,794	1,111	379	34	270	958	109	37	472	956	.270	.319	.459	.778	3,051
61	Al Bumbry	104	1972	1985	25-38	1,496	5,619	5,053	778	1,422	1,096	220	52	54	402	254	92	471	709	.281	.343	.378	.721	1,908
62	Rube Oldring	103	1905	1918	21-34	1,239	5,107	4,690	616	1,268	960	205	76	27	471	197	36	206	407	.270	.307	.364	.671	1,706
63	Denard Span	103	2008	2018	24-34	1,359	5,956	5,326	773	1,498	1,090	265	72	71	490	185	59	515	716	.281	.347	.398	.745	2,120
64	Jacoby Ellsbury	103	2007	2017	23-33	1,235	5,375	4,846	749	1,376	984	241	47	104	512	343	71	399	737	.284	.342	.417	.760	2,023
65	Lloyd Moseby	102	1980	1991	20-31	1,588	6,574	5,815	869	1,494	986	273	66	169	737	280	92	616	1,135	.257	.332	.414	.746	2,406
66	Marlon Byrd	102	2002	2016	24-38	1,573	6,123	5,579	740	1,534	1,025	311	39	159	710	56	31	382	1,234	.275	.329	.430	.759	2,400
67	Shane Victorino	102	2003	2015	22-34	1,299	5,164	4,630	731	1,274	865	231	70	108	489	231	46	381	626	.275	.340	.425	.765	1,969
68	Steve Brodie	102	1890	1902	21-33	1,438	6,342	5,703	886	1,728	1,423	191	89	25	900	289		420	233	.303	.365	.381	.745	2,172
69	Ned Hanlon	102	1880	1892	22-34	1,149	5,005	4,602	824	1,186	941	143	73	29	473	264		391	333	.258	.317	.339	.657	1,562
70	Garry Maddox	101	1972	1986	22-36	1,749	6,777	6,331	777	1,802	1,286	337	62	117	754	248	92	323	781	.285	.320	.413	.733	2,614
71	Willie McGee	100	1982	1999	23-40	2,201	8,188	7,649	1,010	2,254	1,731	350	94	79	856	352	121	448	1,238	.295	.333	.396	.729	3,029
72	Curt Flood	100	1956	1971	18-33	1,759	6,958	6,357	851	1,861	1,461	271	44	85	636	88	73	444	609	.293	.342	.389	.732	2,475
Rk	Player	OPS+	From	To	Age	G	PA	AB	R	H	1B	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB