Friday, November 21, 2025

If there was one MVP: Judge or Ohtani? And why are there two?

Leagues merge.

NFL + AFL = NFL with two conferences; one MVP

NBA + ABA = NBA with two conferences; one MVP

NL + AL = NL and AL (aka MLB); two MVP

Baseball clings to old stuff, including the number of awards and league leaders.

So, had there been one Most Valuable Player (MVP) award since inter league play started in 1997, who would it have been? Start with 2025.

https://www.sports-reference.com/stathead/tiny/4wsyr

Provided by StatheadFound with Stathead. See Full Results.
Generated 11/21/2025.

https://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/majors/2025-batting-leaders.shtml

Wins Above Replacement--all
1.Judge • NYY9.7
2.Sánchez • PHI8.0
3.Ohtani • LAD7.7
4.Skenes • PIT7.7
5.Raleigh • SEA7.4
6.Witt • KCR7.1
7.Perdomo • ARI7.0
8.Rodríguez • SEA6.8
9.Skubal • DET6.5
10.Crochet • BOS6.3

Ohtani pitched 47 innings; otherwise, full time DH. Full time pitchers above: Sanchez, Skenes, Skubal, Crochet

WAR Position Players
1.Judge • NYY9.7
2.Raleigh • SEA7.4
3.Witt • KCR7.1
4.Perdomo • ARI7.0
5.Rodríguez • SEA6.8
6.Ohtani • LAD6.6
7.Soto • NYM6.2
8.Hoerner • CHC6.2
9.Seager • TEX6.2
10.Olson • ATL6.0


Offensive WAR
1.Judge • NYY9.4
2.Raleigh • SEA7.7
3.Soto • NYM7.0
4.Perdomo • ARI6.8
5.Witt • KCR6.7
6.Ohtani • LAD6.7
7.Lindor • NYM6.0
8.Rodríguez • SEA5.8
9.Ramírez • CLE5.7
10.Henderson • BAL5.6


Defensive WAR
1.Clement • TOR2.9
2.Rafaela • BOS2.8
3.Betts • LAD2.6
4.Walls • TBR2.5
5.Hayes • 2TM2.4
6.Seager • TEX2.3
7.Hoerner • CHC2.3
8.Neto • LAA2.2
9.Lopez • MIA2.1
10.Fermin • 2TM2.1

Pick one MVP 29 seasons 2025-1997.  Friday, November 21, 2025

***   The End   ***

No comments: